Components and Schematics

Power Transistor vs MOSFET: Which to Use for Switching

Compare power transistors (BJTs) and MOSFETs for switching: how each is controlled, where energy is lost, and which one suits your switching load.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. What “power transistor” means
  3. How each one is controlled
  4. Losses when switched on
  5. Driving them from a microcontroller
  6. Inductive loads and the flyback diode
  7. Power MOSFET vs MOSFET
  8. MOSFET vs relay
  9. Which one to choose

Short answer

For switching a load on and off, a MOSFET is often the easier part to drive, because its gate is voltage-controlled and draws little steady current. A bipolar power transistor (BJT) needs a continuous base current while it is on, and it usually has a larger on-state voltage drop. Neither is better in every case. The right choice depends on the drive circuit, the current, and the cost.

What “power transistor” means

“Power transistor” is a loose term. It usually refers to a bipolar junction transistor (BJT) designed to handle high current or power, often in a larger package with a metal tab for mounting to a heatsink. MOSFETs and IGBTs are also sold as power devices. When a datasheet or forum post says “power transistor,” check the part number to find out what type it is.

How each one is controlled

  • BJT: a small base current controls a larger collector current. The base has to be driven continuously while the transistor is on, so a base resistor is needed to limit the current from the driving pin.
  • MOSFET: a gate voltage controls a channel between drain and source. Once the gate is charged, very little steady current flows into it. Switching speed depends on the gate capacitance, so fast switching needs a driver that can supply enough current.

Losses when switched on

A saturated BJT has a collector-emitter voltage drop that is often a few tenths of a volt at rated current. At high current, that drop multiplied by the current gives a noticeable amount of heat.

A MOSFET behaves like a resistor when it is on. Its drain-source on-resistance, written R_DS(on), sets the voltage drop as I × R. Some larger power MOSFETs have an on-resistance in the milliohm range, which can give very small drops at high current. On-resistance rises with temperature, so check the datasheet’s curve for your operating temperature.

Driving them from a microcontroller

This is where many beginner circuits go wrong.

  • BJT: use a base resistor between the pin and the base. Check that the pin can supply enough current, and that the transistor’s current gain is high enough to turn the load fully on. A transistor that is not fully on can get hot.
  • MOSFET: check the gate threshold and the R_DS(on) rating at the gate voltage you can supply. Many power MOSFETs are specified at 10 V gate drive and will not fully turn on from a 3.3 V pin. Logic-level MOSFETs are specified at lower gate voltages, often 4.5 V or 5 V, and some are specified at lower still. Read the datasheet’s table for your gate voltage.
  • A MOSFET’s gate is insulated and can be damaged by static discharge. A resistor in series with the gate, and a pull-down resistor from gate to source, keep the gate in a defined state when the pin is floating.

Inductive loads and the flyback diode

Motors, solenoids, and relay coils store energy in a magnetic field. When the switch opens, the voltage across the load can spike. A flyback diode across an inductive DC load gives that current a path to decay safely. Power MOSFETs have a built-in body diode, but it may not be fast or rated enough for every load, so an external diode is often added.

Power MOSFET vs MOSFET

Power MOSFETs and small-signal MOSFETs share the same operating principle. The difference lies in construction and ratings. Power MOSFETs are built to handle higher current and voltage. The is power MOSFET and MOSFET the same? article covers this in more detail.

MOSFET vs relay

A relay uses mechanical contacts. It can switch AC, and it keeps its coil electrically separate from the load. A MOSFET has no moving parts, switches faster, and does not bounce. A single MOSFET is usually used as a DC switch, because its body diode conducts in one direction even when the channel is off. Switching AC needs a different arrangement. The relay article covers relay coils and contacts in more detail.

Which one to choose

  • For a small, low-voltage DC load driven from a microcontroller, a logic-level MOSFET is often the simplest choice.
  • For higher current where a low voltage drop matters, a MOSFET with a low R_DS(on) is usually the better fit.
  • A BJT can still be a sensible, low-cost choice for modest loads, and it is easy to check with a meter. See how to test a transistor with a multimeter.

For either part, read the voltage rating, the continuous current rating, the power dissipation, and the drive requirements on the datasheet before you commit to a design.

The complete guide to components and schematics

Electronic Components Explained: Active vs Passive
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →