Power Supplies

What are the disadvantages of SMPS?

Switch-mode power supplies are efficient but have drawbacks: switching noise, complex circuits, load sensitivity and electrical hazards on the mains side.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Electrical noise
  3. More parts, more ways to fail
  4. Load sensitivity
  5. Mains-side hazards and isolation
  6. Repair is harder than it looks
  7. Does an SMPS convert AC to DC?
  8. When a linear supply still makes sense
  9. Choosing a switch-mode supply

Short answer

Switch-mode power supplies (SMPS) are efficient and compact, but they have real drawbacks. They produce electrical noise, they have more parts that can fail, they can behave badly at very light or very heavy loads, and their mains side is hazardous. These are the trade-offs for efficiency and size, not reasons to avoid switch-mode supplies in general.

Electrical noise

An SMPS switches its transistor on and off at high frequency, typically tens to hundreds of kilohertz. The fast edges cause two kinds of noise:

  • Output ripple and spikes at the switching frequency and its harmonics. A linear supply’s output is usually much quieter.
  • Electromagnetic interference (EMI). Noise can travel back along the mains cable, or radiate from the circuit, and interfere with radios, audio equipment and sensitive measurements.

Good designs reduce this with input and output filters, careful layout and shielding, and they are tested against EMC standards. This is why the certification marks on a supply matter. For audio preamps and precision analog circuits, many builders add a linear regulator after a switch-mode supply to clean up the output.

More parts, more ways to fail

A switch-mode supply contains a control loop, a switching transistor, a transformer or inductor, filter capacitors and protection circuits. Each part is a possible point of failure. A common ageing failure is the electrolytic output capacitor, which dries out over time, especially when it runs hot. A supply that has been running hot for years may show more ripple or fail to start.

Load sensitivity

  • Minimum load. Some designs need a small minimum load to regulate well. Running them at near zero load can make the output unstable or noisy. Check the datasheet or manual.
  • Protection cycling. An overload can trigger a protection shutdown, followed by an automatic retry. The unit then seems to switch on and off repeatedly.
  • Standby losses. At very light loads, the supply’s own consumption can be a larger share of the power it takes from the mains.

Mains-side hazards and isolation

The input side of most switch-mode supplies connects directly to the rectified mains. Its large capacitors can hold a dangerous charge after the unit is unplugged, so do not open sealed units.

Some low-cost designs are non-isolated. That means the output is not electrically separated from the mains, so touching the output or its wiring could be dangerous. Check the label and the certification for any supply you use with exposed connections. Isolated designs are the safer choice for devices people handle.

Repair is harder than it looks

Repairing a switch-mode supply needs care around the mains-side capacitors and high-voltage nodes. Beginners should not open sealed units, and many low-cost units are not worth repairing. Replacing a faulty unit is usually the safer and cheaper option.

Does an SMPS convert AC to DC?

Most switch-mode adapters and PC power supplies do convert AC to DC. They rectify the mains first, then switch the high-voltage DC through a transformer to produce the output. Some switch-mode units are DC-DC converters instead, such as a buck module that takes a DC input. The types of power converters article explains the families.

When a linear supply still makes sense

A linear supply can be the better choice when:

  • Noise matters most, such as with sensitive analog, audio or RF circuits.
  • The voltage drop is small, so the heat from the regulator is also small. The linear power supply circuits guide shows the heat formula.
  • You want few parts and simple repair.

Choosing a switch-mode supply

  • Certification: look for the safety and EMC marks for your country.
  • Rating headroom: choose an output voltage and current with some margin above your load.
  • Minimum load: check whether the supply needs a minimum load to regulate well.
  • Isolation: prefer an isolated design for devices that people handle or connect to other equipment.

For the basics of how supplies convert and regulate power, see DC power supplies explained. The switch in a power system article explains the transistor switch inside an SMPS, as distinct from the mains switch on the unit.

The complete guide to power supplies

DC Power Supplies Explained: Linear, Switching and Variable
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →