Capacitors

Tantalum vs Electrolytic Capacitors: Which to Use and Why

Tantalum vs electrolytic capacitors compared: construction, voltage derating, failure modes, and which to choose for compact rails or bulk filtering.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. How they differ
  3. Polarity markings
  4. Failure modes and safety
  5. Cost and supply
  6. Which to choose
  7. Key takeaways

The short answer

Both tantalum and aluminum electrolytic capacitors are polarized, so both need the correct orientation. Tantalums pack more capacitance into a small space, have lower leakage and are more stable with temperature. They need more voltage margin, and they can fail as a short with more force. Aluminum electrolytics are cheaper, come in higher voltage ratings and are the usual choice for bulk filtering. They dry out with age and can bulge or vent.

For a compact low-voltage rail, a tantalum can be a good choice if you derate it. For bulk filtering on a power supply, an aluminum electrolytic is usually the practical answer.

How they differ

Size and capacitance

Tantalum capacitors give high capacitance in a small package, because the thin oxide layer on the tantalum electrode allows a very thin dielectric. Aluminum electrolytics are often larger for the same capacitance at a given voltage, but they scale easily to very large bulk values.

Voltage rating and derating

Aluminum electrolytics commonly come in higher voltage ratings. Tantalums are usually available at lower voltages, and many manufacturers recommend running them at about half their rated voltage, or at least with a clear margin. Check the datasheet for the derating rule for the part you plan to use. A 10 V tantalum on a 5 V rail follows this kind of margin.

Leakage, ESR and lifespan

Tantalums generally have lower DC leakage current than aluminum electrolytics, and their ESR is often steadier across temperature. Liquid aluminum electrolytics have a higher ESR and a lifespan limited by the electrolyte drying out with heat. See ESR in capacitors for why ESR matters.

Polarity markings

The markings differ, and that catches people out:

  • Aluminum electrolytic: the negative side usually has a stripe with minus signs.
  • Tantalum chip: the positive side is often marked, with a stripe, a notch or a plus sign.

Always read the marking on the part itself, and check the PCB silkscreen. See capacitor polarity for more on reading the leads and symbols.

Failure modes and safety

  • Aluminum electrolytics tend to dry out over time, and they can bulge, leak or vent. They usually give some warning.
  • Tantalums are less forgiving of reverse voltage, voltage spikes and overheating. They often fail as a short circuit, and in some cases the failure is violent, with heat and smoke. Solid polymer tantalum types are often chosen for a safer failure mode.

Use a voltage margin, check polarity, and avoid pushing a tantalum close to its rating. Replace any failed part with one of the same type and rating unless the design calls for a change.

Cost and supply

Aluminum electrolytics are inexpensive and widely available. Tantalums cost more. Tantalum is one of the conflict minerals covered by sourcing rules, which is one reason its supply is more closely watched.

Which to choose

  • Bulk filtering on a power supply: aluminum electrolytic. It gives the most capacitance per cost and handles higher voltages.
  • A compact low-voltage rail or decoupling in a tight space: tantalum or a polymer type, with a voltage margin and correct polarity.
  • Replacing a part in an existing design: match the original type and rating unless you understand why the design chose it.
  • Non-polarized needs: neither part fits. Use ceramic or film. See decoupling and bypass capacitors.

Key takeaways

  • Both types are polarized. Check orientation before soldering.
  • Tantalums give more capacitance per volume and lower leakage, but need voltage margin and can fail as a short.
  • Aluminum electrolytics are cheaper, handle higher voltages and suit bulk filtering, but dry out and can bulge or vent.
  • Choose by job: bulk filtering suits aluminum, while compact low-voltage rails may suit tantalum or polymer types with derating.

The complete guide to capacitors

Capacitors Explained: How They Behave in DC and AC Circuits
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →